Shape the Debate

toggle section menu
National
What Is a Crime? Who Is a Criminal?

Do prisons make you feel safe?

What others said

Yes
9%
No
91%
BackShape the Debate

Anonymous

Incarcerating individuals who have serious polyvictimization histories has to change. Social workers need to be an respected profession that is mandated in the prisons for the prisoners. The state of jails in Tennesssee is horrific for prisonsers while the privatization of prisons is greed based and no improvements for are forthcoming that supports human rights for those incarcerated.

2:14 PM | January 27, 2022

JJ

They only make more criminals

1:13 PM | November 3, 2021

Dominique

The prison system itself is sustained by practices of suppression, white supremacy and hegemony. Workers/runners of the prison system have done far worse than those imprisoned.

2:14 PM | January 5, 2021

Beth

Prisons don't prevent harm, they just punish people after the laws are allegedly broken. Also frequently people are unjustly convicted or are targeted based on their race or financial status. Prisons create and replicate societal hierarchies, resulting in huge abuses of power. Inmates are subject to rape and additional violence by their wardens as well as by other imprisoned people.

6:18 PM | October 17, 2020

martha

So many people in prison are there for actions or behaviors that have been criminalized while those with white skin and class privilege do not serve for similar offenses. Why should I feel safer when affluent white people-- like the students I teach-- can commit the same crimes and remain in our community? I know that with resources and support, most people will make good lives for themselves. Prisons work hard to dehumanize those they incarcerate. There is no added value to incarcerating the vast majority of people behind bars.

12:12 PM | September 10, 2020

Molly Hults

prisons do not rehabilitate, it can be argued that it causes increased criminality because those released have fewer options for employment.

7:19 PM | August 7, 2020

Stephanie Guy

The more I learn, the more I realize that prisons only function to punish not to reform or make communities safer.

6:18 PM | August 6, 2020

Maeve

While those who commit crimes, particularly those of a violent nature, need to be dealt with in some measure (punishment/rehabilitation depending on context), I do not feel that prisons rehabilitate those who might need it and punishes everyone convicted of many different crimes in the same way, not considering if the punishment is just or fitting.

1:01 AM | August 3, 2020

Anonymous

They used to make me feel safe, but now I think they turn people--especially the prison guards-- into monsters

5:17 PM | July 23, 2020

Avalon Betts-Gaston

The people that work in prisons are the most brutal either verbally or physically. Prisons in and of themselves do nothing to rehabilitate people sent to them. It's the individual who rehabilitates themselves despite being in prison.

4:16 PM | July 23, 2020

Pages