Shape the Debate

toggle section menu

Should asylum seekers in the United States be incarcerated?

What others said

BackShape the Debate

Matt Farah

Incarcerating law abiding populations has no basis in common sense. While the laws may not reflect this, the realities of "allowing" asylum seekers to exist in and acclimate to a new society provides the opportunities for those populations to more quickly become fruitful members of society. It also requires administrative needs which in turn provide federal job opportunities for current citizenry.

1:13 PM | June 3, 2021

Adina Langer

There are much cheaper and more humane ways for the U.S. government to keep tabs on asylum seekers while they are awaiting trial. Long-term incarceration violates asylum-seekers' human rights. In addition, it has not proven to be an effective deterrent against mass migration from places where people feel threatened on a daily basis.

5:17 PM | January 20, 2021


Incarceration itself is not helpful and needs to be gotten rid of. Its disgusting to think locking up asylum seekers is even a thing that is being done. Seperation of families, being treated like non humans. I cant believe people can even work in those kinds of places.

10:22 PM | December 21, 2020


We are paying money to keep perfectly capable people in a facility. A waste of our money and their time.

10:22 PM | December 21, 2020